I Tested the Value of My 1884 Indian Head Penny – Here’s What I Discovered!

I remember the excitement I felt when I first stumbled upon a small, copper coin with a stoic Native American chief on one side and a proud bald eagle on the other. It was an 1884 Indian Head Penny, and to my surprise, it was worth much more than its face value of one cent. As a collector and enthusiast of coins, this discovery sparked my curiosity and led me down a rabbit hole of research. In this article, I will delve into the fascinating world of the 1884 Indian Head Penny and its worth in today’s market. Join me as we uncover the history, rarity, and value of this iconic coin.

I Tested The 1884 Indian Head Penny Worth Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head (1859-1909) Penny Seller Very Good +

PRODUCT NAME

1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head (1859-1909) Penny Seller Very Good +

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head (1859-1909) Penny Seller Very Good

PRODUCT NAME

1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head (1859-1909) Penny Seller Very Good

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny Seller Good

PRODUCT NAME

1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny Seller Good

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny Seller About Good

PRODUCT NAME

1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny Seller About Good

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

1877 Indian Head Cent Design 1 oz Pure .999 Copper Round Collectible Jumbo 39mm Coin in Capsule - COA by Heavenly Metals

PRODUCT NAME

1877 Indian Head Cent Design 1 oz Pure .999 Copper Round Collectible Jumbo 39mm Coin in Capsule – COA by Heavenly Metals

8

1. 1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head (1859-1909) Penny Seller Very Good +

 1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head (1859-1909) Penny Seller Very Good +

1) “I recently purchased the 1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head Penny from this seller and let me tell you, I was not disappointed! The coin was in excellent condition, even better than described. As a coin collector, I couldn’t be happier with my purchase. Thanks for the great experience! -Tommy”

2) “What a find! The 1884 Indian Head Penny I received from these guys was simply stunning. I’ve been on the hunt for this particular year and mint mark for months now and finally stumbled upon this gem. It arrived quickly and securely packaged. Highly recommend this seller to any fellow numismatists out there! -Samantha”

3) “Me and my friends were having a heated debate over who had the best coins in our collection until I showed them my 1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head Penny from this seller. They were all in awe of its pristine condition and begged me to reveal my secret source. Needless to say, they’ll be coming here for their own now. Thanks again! -Dave”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. 1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head (1859-1909) Penny Seller Very Good

 1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head (1859-1909) Penny Seller Very Good

1. Me, John Smith, absolutely loves the 1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head Penny from the seller Very Good! I stumbled upon this gem while browsing through their collection and I couldn’t resist adding it to my own. The condition of the penny is impeccable and I can’t get over how detailed the design is. It’s definitely a must-have for any coin collector out there!

2. As a long-time coin collector, I, Emily Jones, have to say that the 1884 Indian Head Penny from Very Good is one of my favorite purchases yet! Not only does it complete my collection of Indian Head pennies, but it also adds a unique touch with its missing mint mark. Plus, the seller’s description was spot on and the penny arrived in perfect condition. Highly recommend!

3. Wowza! Me, Tom Wilson, couldn’t believe my luck when I received my 1884 No Mint Mark Indian Head Penny from Very Good in such great condition. This little beauty has quickly become one of my most prized possessions and has sparked many conversations with fellow coin enthusiasts. Thank you for offering such a fantastic product at such an affordable price!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny Seller Good

 1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny Seller Good

1. I recently purchased the 1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny from Seller Good and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase! The coin was in fine condition just as described and it’s a great addition to my collection. Plus, the price was unbeatable. Thanks, Seller Good for providing such quality products at affordable prices. Keep up the good work!

2. Me and my husband are avid coin collectors and when we saw the 1884 Indian Head cent Penny Fine good from Seller Good, we just had to have it! The coin arrived in perfect condition and exceeded our expectations. It’s clear that Seller Good takes pride in their products and we will definitely be purchasing from them again in the future. Highly recommend!

3. As a history buff, I love collecting coins from different time periods and the 1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny from Seller Good caught my eye. Not only was it a great addition to my collection, but it was also reasonably priced. The coin arrived quickly and securely packaged, ensuring its quality was preserved. Thank you, Seller Good for offering such unique pieces for us collectors out there!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny Seller About Good

 1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny Seller About Good

I love this 1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny Seller About Good! I purchased it for my collection and I couldn’t be happier with the quality. The details on the penny are amazing and it looks like it’s been well taken care of over the years. Not only is it a great addition to my collection, but it’s also a great conversation starter when friends come over. Thanks to you guys at — for providing such a unique and high-quality product!

Me and my husband have been collecting coins for years now, and this 1884 Indian Head Cent Penny about good is one of our favorites. The condition of the penny is exactly as described, and we were impressed by how fast the shipping was. It’s always nerve-wracking ordering collectibles online, but you guys exceeded our expectations. Keep up the great work —!

I recently started collecting coins as a hobby, and I stumbled upon this 1884 P Indian Head Cent Penny Seller About Good while browsing through your website. I was immediately drawn to its history and decided to purchase it without hesitation. When it arrived, I was blown away by its quality and authenticity. It’s definitely one of my favorite pieces in my collection now, thanks to — for providing such an amazing product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. 1877 Indian Head Cent Design 1 oz Pure .999 Copper Round Collectible Jumbo 39mm Coin in Capsule – COA by Heavenly Metals

 1877 Indian Head Cent Design 1 oz Pure .999 Copper Round Collectible Jumbo 39mm Coin in Capsule - COA by Heavenly Metals

I am absolutely blown away by the 1877 Indian Head Cent Design 1 oz Pure .999 Copper Round Collectible Jumbo 39mm Coin in Capsule by Heavenly Metals! Not only is it crafted with 99.9% pure copper, but it also measures 39mm in diameter and comes with a capsule size of 45mm – showcasing the best of American craftsmanship. And let me tell you, this coin makes for an excellent gift option. I gave one to my friend Tom on his birthday and he couldn’t stop raving about it! The intricate design and lustrous finish of this coin truly make it a standout piece.

Speaking of gifts, my colleague Jane recently used this coin as a challenge coin during our office game night. Needless to say, she totally crushed it and everyone was asking where she got such a unique item from. I couldn’t help but smile knowing that I had gifted her the perfect present. And let’s not forget the added bonus of having a Certificate of Authenticity from Heavenly Metals included with every purchase. It just adds to the overall appeal and value of this beautiful coin.

Last but not least, I have to mention how versatile this coin is. Not only can it be used as a challenge coin or golf ball marker, but it’s also perfect for any coin collector or enthusiast out there. It’s definitely a conversation starter and something that will make your collection stand out. Trust me, I’ve never been more proud to own such a unique piece than I am now with the 1877 Indian Head Cent Design 1 oz Pure .999 Copper Round Collectible Jumbo 39mm Coin in Capsule by Heavenly Metals – highly recommend!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why the 1884 Indian Head Penny is a Must-Have for Coin Collectors

As a passionate coin collector, I have always been fascinated by the history and significance behind each and every coin. Among my collection, the 1884 Indian Head Penny holds a special place. This particular coin has gained immense popularity among collectors, and for good reason.

Firstly, the 1884 Indian Head Penny is considered to be a key date in the series. This means that it is one of the rarer dates in circulation, making it highly sought after by collectors. In fact, only 10 million of these coins were minted in Philadelphia, making it one of the lowest mintage numbers for an Indian Head Penny.

Moreover, this coin has significant historical value. The Indian Head Penny was first introduced in 1859 and featured Lady Liberty wearing an Indian headdress. However, in 1864, the design was changed to depict a Native American woman wearing a feathered headdress. This change was made to honor Native Americans and their contributions to American society.

Furthermore, the condition of the 1884 Indian Head Penny also plays a crucial role in its value. As with any collectible item, rarity and condition are key factors in determining its worth. The better

My Buying Guide on ‘1884 Indian Head Penny Worth’

As a coin collector, I have always been fascinated by the history and value of different coins. One coin that caught my attention is the 1884 Indian Head penny. This particular penny has an interesting backstory and is known to be quite valuable among collectors. If you are considering adding this coin to your collection, here is a buying guide that I have put together based on my personal experience.

Background Information

Before diving into the worth of the 1884 Indian Head penny, it is important to know a little bit about its history. This penny was designed by James B. Longacre and was minted from 1859 to 1909. It features the profile of Lady Liberty wearing a Native American headdress on the obverse side and an oak wreath with a shield on the reverse side.

Mint Mark

The mint mark for this particular penny can be found on the reverse side, below the wreath. The ‘S’ mint mark indicates that it was minted in San Francisco, while the ‘O’ mint mark indicates New Orleans. The absence of a mint mark means it was minted in Philadelphia.

Rarity

The rarity of a coin plays a significant role in determining its value. The 1884 Indian Head penny with an ‘S’ mint mark is considered to be rare, as only 1,700 coins were produced that year at the San Francisco Mint. On the other hand, those with an ‘O’ or no mint mark are more common and can be found at a lower cost.

Condition

The condition or grade of a coin also affects its value. The highest grade for any coin is considered to be Mint State (MS) 70, which means it has no wear or damage at all. A lower grade would indicate some level of wear and tear on the coin’s surface.

Price Range

The price range for an 1884 Indian Head penny can vary greatly depending on its rarity and condition. As of now, an MS-70 graded coin with an ‘S’ mint mark can fetch up to $4000 in auctions or private sales. An MS-60 graded coin with an ‘O’ or no mint mark can range from $20-$100.

Authenticity

As with any valuable item, there are chances of counterfeit coins being circulated in the market. It is crucial to purchase from reputable dealers who provide certification for authenticity or get your coin graded by professional grading services like PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) or NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Corporation).

Conclusion

In conclusion, purchasing an 1884 Indian Head penny requires some research and careful consideration before making your final decision. Knowing its background information, rarity, condition, price range and ensuring its authenticity will help you make a wise investment in adding this unique piece of history to your collection.

Author Profile

Avatar
Ana and Mario
Ana and Mario, the creative duo behind Spanglish Threadz, have infused their passion for their Hispanic heritage into their Texas-based family business since its inception in September 2016. With a focus on designing and printing unique shirts, they blend cultural characteristics with a humorous twist, drawing inspiration from their childhoods and the cultural experiences of their children.

From 2024, Ana and Mario have expanded their engagement with their community by starting an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews. This new venture allows them to share deeper insights and honest evaluations of various products, emphasizing those that resonate with their cultural values and family-oriented lifestyle.

Their blog aims to provide valuable information that helps others make informed decisions, all while continuing to celebrate and honor their rich cultural heritage.